Irish compromise omits ETS2, Poland wants Modernisation Fund doubled
The Irish presidency's new compromise does not address ETS2, despite Polish demands. The proposal only partially eases the conditions for companies receiving free emission allowances.

Christian Lue · Unsplash License
- 0views
- 0likes and saves
- 0skips
In brief
- The Irish presidency's new draft reform of the EU ETS does not address ETS2, despite the Polish demand raised on 6 November.
- The draft keeps the Modernisation Fund without increasing its pool, maintaining 100 million allowances.
- Conditions for free allowances will be eased, but companies will still have to present emission reduction plans.
- The vote in the European Parliament's environment committee on the position has been postponed to 7 December.
Polish demands without response
The Polish representative raised the ETS2 demand during a bilateral meeting with the Irish presidency on 6 November (Zła wiadomość w sprawie ETS2 dla Warszawy i gra va banque polskich europosłów – RMF24). However, the presidency's next document contains no reference to this system. The presidency notes that its proposal does not change the overall level of climate ambition or the solidarity mechanisms. Poland wants the entry into force of ETS2 postponed or the system made voluntary. Under the current rules, the system is due to start in 2028 (Porażka Polski ws. ETS2. Niemcy triumfują, choć walka nadal trwa – WNP.pl).
Modernisation Fund without a larger pool
The Irish draft keeps the Modernisation Fund but does not increase its basic pool. The presidency proposes maintaining 100 million allowances for the countries using the Fund, while Poland demanded they be doubled.
Free allowances with conditions
The rules for granting companies free emission allowances are set to be eased. However, businesses will still have to present investment plans for reducing emissions, and exemptions are foreseen, including for smaller companies. Poland wants this conditionality dropped entirely. The proposal also does not meet Polish expectations for a slower pace of emission reductions.
Earlier setback in the EP
In the European Parliament's Industry Committee, attempts by Polish MEPs to push the ETS2 issue through individual votes failed, and the compromise worked out on the EU ETS reform was rejected (Ten zwrot w sprawie emisji CO2 może zaboleć. Polskie poprawki przepadły – WNP.pl). Polish MEPs wanted ETS2 postponed until 2031, but no roll-call vote on this took place (Porażka polskich europosłów w sprawie ETS2. Decydująca walka w grudniu – RMF24).
Positions of Germany and Ireland
German Chancellor Friedrich Merz clearly opposes changes to ETS2, and Ireland does not intend to introduce them in its compromise. Given this arrangement, Polish demands have little chance of being taken into account in the current form of the negotiations.
Upcoming deadlines
The vote in the European Parliament's environment committee on the position on the ETS reform has been moved from 1 to 7 December. However, this provision appears only in the preamble, not in the articles of the document, so it does not establish a specific mechanism.
Read also
- ETS: Bruksela wstrzymuje kasowanie uprawnień do emisji. Warszawa zgodziła się na kompromis
- Przemysł w UE ma płacić mniej za emisje dzięki dodatkowym bezpłatnym uprawnieniom
Sources
- [1]
Zła wiadomość w sprawie ETS2 dla Warszawy i gra va banque polskich europosłów· RMF24 - [2]
Porażka Polski ws. ETS2. Niemcy triumfują, choć walka nadal trwa· WNP.pl - [3]
Porażka polskich europosłów w sprawie ETS2. Decydująca walka w grudniu· RMF24 - [4]
Ten zwrot w sprawie emisji CO2 może zaboleć. Polskie poprawki przepadły· WNP.pl
Discussion0
- No comments from this perspective yet. Be the first.