KSeF Confirms Invoice Origin, Not Its Authenticity. Two Approaches to Booking Doubtful Documents
The KSeF system confirms who issued an invoice and that it has not been altered, but it does not verify whether the transaction actually took place. Prof. Witold Modzelewski explains how a taxpayer and an accounting firm may act in such a situation.

KOBU Agency · Unsplash License
- 0views
- 0likes and saves
- 0skips
In brief
- KSeF confirms the issuer of an invoice and that it has not been changed, but not the truthfulness of the transaction.
- Prof. Witold Modzelewski identifies two approaches: booking a formally correct invoice, or clarifying doubts before booking.
- If there is suspicion of unreliability, it is worth gathering the contract, proofs of receipt, correspondence and proofs of payment.
- Automatic loading of invoices into the books may also include false or erroneous documents.
Origin of an invoice and reliability of the transaction
The Krajowy System e-Faktur (National e-Invoice System) certifies who issued the invoice and whether the document has remained unchanged after its issuance (KSeF potwierdza "autentyczność pochodzenia” także fałszywych faktur. Co powinien zrobić podatnik lub księgowy, gdy pobierze z KSeF taką fakturę? – Infor.pl). However, it does not verify whether the transaction actually took place or whether the goods or services described on the document were delivered. As prof. Witold Modzelewski points out, an invoice may therefore be formally authentic while certifying something untrue.
Two approaches to doubtful invoices
Prof. Modzelewski describes at least two possible attitudes. The first consists of booking a formally correct invoice downloaded from KSeF, on the assumption that assessing its content remains the responsibility of control authorities. The second assumes that an accountant who has justified doubts about the reality of the transaction should first clarify the matter with the counterparty and document the course of this verification, and only then decide whether to book the invoice.
Documents worth gathering
When unreliability of an invoice is suspected, it is worth collecting documents confirming the course of the transaction: the contract, the order, proofs of receipt, correspondence with the counterparty and proofs of payment. The absence of such documents, or discrepancies between them and the content of the invoice, constitute grounds for further analysis.
Automatic loading into the books
KSeF allows structured invoices to be automatically transferred to the purchase register, which is often presented as its main advantage (Czy „automatyczne zaczytanie” faktury ustrukturyzowanej do ksiąg może być czynem zabronionym? Problem z fakturami „zerującymi” – Infor.pl). This function has its consequences, however: the system may load invoices that are false, erroneous or reissued, and the legal effects of such loading are the subject of questions from taxpayers.
Liability in the event of an audit
Since KSeF does not examine the substantive content of an invoice, in the event of an audit it is largely the taxpayer who must demonstrate the reliability of the transaction. For this reason, accounting firms should agree with their clients on rules for handling documents raising doubts and record the decisions taken in their documentation.
Sources
Discussion0
- No comments from this perspective yet. Be the first.