Unconstitutional Labour Inspectorate Act? Dispute Over the Inspectorate's Powers to Convert Contracts
The act giving the State Labour Inspectorate the power to convert civil-law contracts into employment contracts is still awaiting review by the Constitutional Tribunal, while experts disagree over whether it is consistent with the constitution.

Anastassia Anufrieva · Unsplash License
- 0views
- 0likes and saves
- 0skips
In brief
- The act gives the National Labour Inspectorate (Państwowa Inspekcja Pracy) the power to convert civil-law contracts into employment contracts by way of an administrative decision.
- The case awaits review by the Constitutional Tribunal (Trybunał Konstytucyjny), and the Federation of Polish Entrepreneurs (Federacja Przedsiębiorców Polskich) points to doubts about the act's compliance with the constitution.
- The date when the Tribunal will begin its work remains unknown, which keeps uncertainty in place for entrepreneurs.
Inspectorate decision instead of a court
The new provisions allow labour inspectors to convert a civil-law contract into an employment contract by way of an administrative decision (Ustawa o PIP jednak niekonstytucyjna? – Prawo.pl). Critics argue that such a ruling not only confirms the existence of an employment relationship, but may also cause that relationship to come into existence in legal circulation. The drafters, however, claimed that the aim is only to formally establish a relationship that already exists.
Dispute over constitutionality
The act awaits review by the Constitutional Tribunal (Czy ustawa o PIP jest konstytucyjna – prawo.pl). The Federation of Polish Entrepreneurs presented a legal opinion in which it points to doubts about the compliance of the solution with the constitution. According to the federation, the most contentious issue is whether the administration may independently shape legal relationships that until now have been decided by labour courts.
No set date
It is not known whether or when the Tribunal will begin working in its full composition, which prolongs the period of uncertainty. It remains an open question whether the inspectorate should apply the new provisions immediately or suspend decisions until a judgment is issued. For entrepreneurs who commission work under civil-law contracts, this means the risk of inspection and conversion of contracts without the possibility of a quick defence before a court.
Sources
Discussion0
- No comments from this perspective yet. Be the first.
