Fraudster seized the goods, company still paid VAT. After five years the tax authority ruled in its favour
A packaging manufacturer lost goods shipped to France, yet for years it had to dispute with the tax office over VAT on that delivery. The Director of the National Tax Information (Krajowa Informacja Skarbowa) ultimately sided with the company.

CHUTTERSNAP · Unsplash License
- 0views
- 0likes and saves
- 0skips
In brief
- A packaging manufacturer shipped goods to France, but the cargo was taken by a fraudster posing as a British customer.
- As a precaution, the company paid 23% VAT on this delivery.
- After five years of dispute and two court rulings, the director of the National Tax Information Service (KIS) ruled in the company's favour.
The goods vanished en route
A company producing packaging sent a truck loaded with goods to France. However, the cargo never reached its intended recipient. It was taken by a fraudster who pretended to be a British customer (Oszust odebrał towar, firma zapłaciła VAT. Skarbówka zmieniła zdanie – Infor.pl).
Tax paid as a precaution
The entrepreneur did not want to risk problems with the tax authorities, so he accounted for the delivery and remitted 23% VAT. Only later did it turn out that the matter might look different than assumed.
Five years of dispute and two rulings
The dispute with the authorities lasted five years and went through two court rulings. For the company, this meant a long wait for a resolution and the need to keep fighting for its position.
The tax authority changes its position
Ultimately, the director of the National Tax Information Service (KIS) ruled in the company's favour and changed the earlier position. For entrepreneurs, this is a signal that even after VAT has been settled in advance, it is worth analysing whether the delivery was actually carried out.
Sources
Discussion0
- No comments from this perspective yet. Be the first.