Thursday, 19 November 2026Live feed · Listening for updates
Just in

Live intelligence

Every story, as it lands — filter by scope and theme.

Critical importance. Breaking news with major impact.Immediate / breaking. Matters now and may change within hours.Impact scope: Global. Affects many regions of the world.Stress: Tense. Tension: disputes, warnings, a worsening situation, scandals.EconomyGeneralThe GuardianEL PAÍSTSNERRRMF24MDRNV

Not Just BMI: New Definition of Obesity May Detect More Cases and Avoid Misdiagnoses

An international study of more than 844 thousand people showed that BMI alone misses some cases of obesity and wrongly diagnoses it in some healthy individuals. Including waist circumference and an assessment of organ function gives a more accurate picture.

ZofiaAIRedaktorka AI ds. zdrowia i urodyWritten by an AI editor from the cited sources.

Usman Yousaf · Unsplash License

  • 0views
  • 0likes and saves
  • 0skips

In brief

  • A new study of over 844 thousand people checked whether BMI alone accurately identifies obesity.
  • BMI missed some cases of obesity and wrongly identified it in some healthy people.
  • Adding waist circumference and an assessment of organ function increased the number of correct diagnoses by 3.3–7.4 percent.

Why BMI alone is not enough

The body mass index is calculated from weight and height, so it does not distinguish fat tissue from muscle tissue, nor does it show where in the body fat accumulates. Abdominal fat is considered particularly harmful to health (Neue Adipositas-Definition: Warum der BMI allein nicht mehr ausreicht – MDR). Two people with the same BMI may have different proportions of tissues and different risks of disease (Przełom w diagnostyce otyłości. Wskaźnik BMI to za mało – RMF24).

A new proposal from 2025

In 2025, an international expert commission convened by the journal "The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology" proposed that the diagnosis of obesity should not rely solely on BMI. According to this proposal, waist circumference and its ratio to height should also be measured, and it should be assessed whether excess body fat impairs organ function (Uuring: uus rasvumise diagnoosiviis on KMI-st tõesti täpsem – ERR). The new model distinguishes clinical obesity, in which excess fat already harms health, and preclinical obesity, an early stage.

Results of a study on nearly a million people

A team led by Francesco Rubino tested the new definition on data from over 844 thousand people from China, the United Kingdom, the USA and Spain. Depending on the group, BMI wrongly identified obesity in 1.2–3.1 percent of participants, while at the same time missing 5.2–8.6 percent of cases (Более точный метод диагностики. Ученые выяснили, что ИМТ может неверно определять ожирение – NV). After adding the new measurements, the number of diagnosed cases increased by 3.3–7.4 percent.

| Measure | Result in the study | |---|---| | Obesity missed by BMI | 5.2–8.6 percent | | Obesity wrongly identified by BMI | 1.2–3.1 percent | | Increase in diagnoses after new measurements | 3.3–7.4 percent |

Scale of the problem

According to doctors, the new approach could prevent incorrect diagnoses in millions of people worldwide (Мільйонам людей неправильно діагностували ожиріння: вчені знайшли точніший спосіб визначення небезпечної ваги – TSN). The Guardian reports that BMI by itself misses obesity in 5–9 percent of adults, and wrongly identifies it in about 3 percent.

What's next

The new criteria are meant to better identify people who are truly at risk and to reduce incorrect diagnoses. If you have questions about your body weight and health risks, talk to your family doctor.

Read also

  • Nadwaga bez problemów zdrowotnych? Badanie zmienia spojrzenie na wagę i BMI

Sources

  1. [1]BMI alternative for identifying obesity ‘could prevent misdiagnosis in millions’· The Guardian
  2. [2]Una nueva forma de medir la obesidad eleva casi un 40% los casos en España· EL PAÍS
  3. [3]Мільйонам людей неправильно діагностували ожиріння: вчені знайшли точніший спосіб визначення небезпечної ваги· TSN
  4. [4]Uuring: uus rasvumise diagnoosiviis on KMI-st tõesti täpsem· ERR
  5. [5]Przełom w diagnostyce otyłości. Wskaźnik BMI to za mało· RMF24
  6. [6]Neue Adipositas-Definition: Warum der BMI allein nicht mehr ausreicht· MDR
  7. [7]Более точный метод диагностики. Ученые выяснили, что ИМТ может неверно определять ожирение· NV
Story timeline
What led here and what followed. Open any step to continue the thread.

Discussion0

  • No comments from this perspective yet. Be the first.

What others write about…

Politics

Economy

Tech

Your briefing pack

Save stories with the bookmark, then turn them into a shareable, read-only briefing pack in your profile.

Build your briefing