BMI Alone Is Not Enough: New Definition of Obesity Detects More Cases and Less Often Mislabels Healthy People
An international study of more than 844 thousand adults showed that the body mass index misses some people with obesity and wrongly diagnoses it in some healthy individuals. A proposal that takes waist circumference and organ condition into account gives a more accurate picture.

Vitaly Gariev · Unsplash License
- 0views
- 0likes and saves
- 0skips
In brief
- A study of more than 844 thousand adults examined whether body mass index alone reliably identifies obesity.
- BMI missed some people with obesity and wrongly flagged some healthy people as having it.
- New criteria take waist circumference and organ health into account and distinguish clinical from preclinical obesity.
Why body mass index alone falls short
BMI is calculated from weight and height, so it does not distinguish fat tissue from muscle tissue or show where in the body fat accumulates. Fat around the abdomen is considered especially dangerous to health (Neue Adipositas-Definition: Warum der BMI allein nicht mehr ausreicht – MDR). Two people with identical BMI may have different proportions of tissues and different risks of disease (Przełom w diagnostyce otyłości. Wskaźnik BMI to za mało – RMF24).
Results from a study of more than 844 thousand people
A team of researchers led by Francesco Rubino tested the new criteria on data from China, the United Kingdom, the USA and Spain. Using BMI alone, obesity went unrecognized in 8.6 percent of participants, and in 3.1 percent it was wrongly considered present (Более точный метод диагностики. Ученые выяснили, что ИМТ может неверно определять ожирение – NV).
Two stages instead of a single threshold
In 2025, an international expert commission, convened under a medical journal, proposed that diagnosis should not rest on BMI alone (Uuring: uus rasvumise diagnoosiviis on KMI-st tõesti täpsem – ERR). The new model distinguishes clinical obesity, in which excess fat already harms organs, from preclinical obesity, when the damage is not yet visible. Waist circumference and its ratio to height help determine which group a patient belongs to.
What this means for patients
The researchers stress that incorrect classification could affect tens of millions of people worldwide (Мільйонам людей неправильно діагностували ожиріння: вчені знайшли точніший спосіб визначення небезпечної ваги – TSN). Doctors could therefore check waist circumference and organ health alongside weight, instead of relying on a single indicator. However, changes to official criteria require further research and decisions by medical societies.
Sources
- [1]
Мільйонам людей неправильно діагностували ожиріння: вчені знайшли точніший спосіб визначення небезпечної ваги· TSN - [2]
Uuring: uus rasvumise diagnoosiviis on KMI-st tõesti täpsem· ERR - [3]
Przełom w diagnostyce otyłości. Wskaźnik BMI to za mało· RMF24 - [4]
Neue Adipositas-Definition: Warum der BMI allein nicht mehr ausreicht· MDR - [5]
Более точный метод диагностики. Ученые выяснили, что ИМТ может неверно определять ожирение· NV
Discussion0
- No comments from this perspective yet. Be the first.