Act on the National Labour Inspectorate unconstitutional after all? Dispute over the inspectorate's new powers
New powers of the National Labour Inspectorate to convert civil-law contracts into employment contracts raise constitutional doubts, and the act still awaits review by the Constitutional Tribunal.

Marco Oriolesi · Unsplash License
- 0views
- 0likes and saves
- 0skips
In brief
- New powers of the Labour Inspectorate (PIP) allow converting civil-law contracts into employment contracts by way of an administrative decision.
- Some lawyers believe the provisions may be unconstitutional, as they interfere with civil-law relationships.
- The law has not yet been reviewed by the Constitutional Tribunal, and entrepreneurs have until 8 July 2027 to put their contracts in order.
Dispute over inspection decisions
The law gives District Labour Inspectorates the power to issue administrative decisions that may convert a civil-law contract into an employment contract (Ustawa o PIP jednak niekonstytucyjna? – Prawo.pl). According to experts cited in this matter, an inspection decision not only confirms the existence of an employment relationship but may also be the basis for its creation in the legal system. The drafters presented these provisions as a mere confirmation of an already existing employment relationship, which some lawyers dispute.
Constitutional objections
Lawyers point to the possible incompatibility of the provisions with the constitution, and Prawo.pl describes these doubts in its analysis (Czy ustawa o PIP jest konstytucyjna – prawo.pl). Critics note that the administration would interfere in civil-law relationships between the parties to a contract, which in their view goes beyond the tasks of a supervisory body for labour law.
No Tribunal review
The law has still not been verified by the Constitutional Tribunal. It is unclear whether and when the Tribunal will begin working in full composition, which leaves uncertainty as to the binding force of the new powers. The provisions have been in force since 8 July 2026, and companies have until 8 July 2027 to put their contracts in order. Employers engaging people under civil-law contracts are not certain whether an inspection will end with the contract being converted.
What next
If the Tribunal finds the provisions incompatible with the constitution, the new powers of the inspectorate will not be applicable. Until a ruling is issued, entrepreneurs should review the civil-law contracts they use and check whether their nature corresponds to the work actually performed.
Also read
- PIP intensyfikuje kontrole umów cywilnoprawnych i B2B w firmach
Sources
Discussion0
- No comments from this perspective yet. Be the first.
